
This recipe may help you determine which tastes better for Old Fashioned cocktails. But what’s the cheapest bourbon for Old Fashioned? Taste Test: Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe However, since rye production is lower than corn and it is harder to distill, the price of rye whiskey is a little higher than bourbon. You can purchase a bottle of these liquors for as low as $20. But which rye whiskey brand is good for Old-fashioned cocktails? Budgetīoth bourbons and rye whiskeys are affordable.

However, different brands offer different alcohol content, so it’s up to you to decide whether you’re up for a higher-proof spirit or not. According to U.S regulations, they should be bottled with at least 40% ABV. Alcohol Contentīourbons and rye whiskeys should be distilled to no more than 160-proof or 80% alcohol by volume. Meanwhile, rye has bitter flavors with a strong kick that light drinkers may not like. It also has caramel, oak, and vanilla notes that balance the flavors. Smoothness Levelīourbon is smoother and lighter than rye because it uses more wheat and corn than rye. It also has a low sugar content and is low in calories. Its spiciness stands out among the flavors of bitters and sugar. Rye whiskey packs a punch that keeps you wanting more glasses of the classic cocktail. Rye is spicy, while bourbon somehow tastes sweet. Sometimes, a little bit of spice tastes good in an Old Fashioned. There are many factors to consider to tell if the liquors are high-quality, like flavor, age, texture, aroma, and drinkability.īoth rye whiskey and bourbon are great base spirits for Old Fashioned cocktails because each has unique flavors that cater to every person’s preference. QualityĪ quality rye whiskey or bourbon doesn’t always have to be expensive.

On the other hand, bourbon has vanilla, toasted oak, chocolate, caramel, cloves, peppers, and nutmeg tasting notes. It’s also smooth and accentuates an Old Fashioned’s silkiness. You’ll taste notes of vanilla or caramel against its lively spiciness. Rye whiskey has a distinct flavor profile that makes it stand out.

However, as rye whiskey has complex flavors and a little bit of spice, it will still be great in an Old Fashioned. What we like about bourbon is that it doesn’t have the burn despite having a strong alcohol taste. It also has a strong profile that can hold up to the flavors of bitters and sugar even after dilution. Which Is Better For Old Fashioned, Bourbon, or Rye?īourbon is better for an Old Fashioned than rye because it is mellow and has a balance of flavors perfect for a simple and classic cocktail. Taste Test: Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe.Which Is Better For Old Fashioned, Bourbon, or Rye?.
